March 2018


«Architecton: proceedings of higher education» № 49 March 2015

Theory of architecture

Kiyanenko Konstantin V.

Doctor of Architecture,
Professor, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning
Vologda State University
Vologda, Russia, e-mail: design@mh.vstu.edu.ru


In the sociology of the city, housing, urban planning and architecture, the question of whether residents with differing income and property levels should be separated is one of the central and debatable issues. Since both strategies are possible in practice, the choice in favour of one of them depends on actual values and criteria of evaluation. The article makes an attempt to consider segregation and integration in the light of the concept of "sustainability" and its axiological toolkit. The concept of "sustainability" is extended to include social meanings. The attitude toward social spatial segregation is examined in the context of international and national sociology, architecture, and modern-day planning practice against the criterion of sustainability of urban communities. Each of these two strategies is evaluated from the opposing standpoints associated with social status and income level and related to urban communities and society as a whole. Planning actions to produce a sustainable integrated city and architectural complex are considered.

Key words: socio-territorial segregation, social and property-status mix, sustainable city


1. Regulations СП 42.1330.2011. (2010) Urban Planning. Planning and Construction of Urban and Rural Settlements. Introduction 2011–20-05. Moscow: Minregion Rossii (in Russian)

2. Charter of European Cities and Towns Towards Sustainability (Allborg Charter). Allborg, Denmark, 1994. [online]. Available from: http://www.ecology.donbass.com/articles-pdf/aalborgcharter_russian.pdf (in Russian)

3. Menova, N.F. (2006) Social Aspects of Sustainable Development of Cities [online] Taxes. Innovation. Capital. No. 1–3. Available from: http://nic.pirit.info/200607/136.htm (in Russian)

4. Gorbunova, M.Yu. (2008) General Sociology. Moscow: Эксмо [online]. Available from: http://www.gramotey.com/?open_file=1269052822 (in Russian)

5. Vagin, V.V. (2000) Sociology of the City. Moscow: Moscow Public Scientific Foundation [online] Available from: http://refdb.ru/look/2559656-pall.html (in Russian)

6. Antipin, P.V. (2000) Specific Features of Social Zoning of Perm Urban Space. In: Russian Urban Space. Moscow: Moscow Public Scientific Foundation (in Russian)

7. The Vancouver Declaration on Human Settlements. United Nations Conference on Human Settlements. Vancouver, Canada. 1976 [online]. Available from: http://ww2.unhabitat.org/declarations/The_Vancouver_Declaration.pdf (in Russian)

8. The Istanbul Declaration on Human Settlements. Istanbul, Turkey: UN-HABITAT. [online]. Available from: http://www.unhabitat.ru/assets/files/publication/sd.pdf (in Russian)

9. Gnatyuk, V.S. (2010) «Sustainability of Social Development»: Towards the Definition of the Concept. Advances in Current Natural Sciences, No.9. (in Russian)

10. Shanghai Declaration. World Expo 2010. Shanghai, 31 October 2010. [online]. Available from: http://www.rusdb.ru/shanhai_decl (in Russian)

11. Sivograkov, О.V. (2008) Indicators of Sustainable Development of a Local Community (How to assess the outcomes of a local agenda 21). Minsk: Propylea [online] Available from: http://ibb.by/sites/default/files/ur5-ndikatoren_buch.pdf (in Russian)

12. Castells, M. (2000) The Information Age: Economy, Society, Culture. Translation from English ed. by O.I. Shkaratan. Moscow: Higher School of Economics [online]. Available from: http://www.gumer.info/bibliotek_Buks/Polit/kastel/index.php (in Russian)

13. Bauman, Z. (2004) Globalization. The Human Consequences. Translated from English by M.L.Korobochkin. Moscow: Ves’ Mir [online]. Available from: http://www.diplomplus.ru/doc/stat/bauman.pdf (in Russian)

14. Sennet, R. (2008) Capitalism and the City: Globalisation, Flexibility and Indifference. Logos 3 (66) (in Russian)

15. Sassen, S. (2005) Global Cities: Postindustrial Production Sites. Prognosis, No. 4. [online]. Available from: http://reftrend.ru/637881.html (in Russian)

16. Sassen, S. (2008) Writing the City Spatially. Logos. No. 3. [online]. Available from: http://www.intelros.ru/pdf/logos_03_2008/07.pdf (in Russian)

17. Knight, R. (1993) Sustainable Development: Sustainable Cities. International Social Science Journal. No. 2. P.43-69 (in Russian)

18. Torino Declaration on Sustainability and Cultural Diversity. (2008) Torino: UIA. [online]. Available from: http://www.archinfo.ru/publications/item/410/ (in Russian)

19. Low, S. (2001) The Edge and the Center: Gated Communities and the Discourse of Urban Fear. American Anthropologist.Vol.103. No.1. [online]. P. 45-58. Available from: http://homepages.uni-tuebingen.de/schamma.schahadat/Intimitaetsprojekt/N...

20. Blyakher, L. (2000) Spatial Segregation of Khabarovsk: Theoretico-Methodological Essays. In: Russian Urban Space. Moscow: Moscow Public Scientific Foundation (in Russian)

21. Cheshkova, А. (2000) Methodological Approaches to Studying Urban Spatial Segregation. In: Russian Urban Space. Moscow: Moscow Public Scientific Foundation (in Russian)

22. Vendina, О. (2004) Could Ethnic Enclaves Emerge in Moscow? Vestnik obshchestvennogo mneniya. No. 3 (in Russian)

23. Programme of Economic Development of Moscow. Ch. V. Financial Mechanisms for Ensuring the Accessibility of Housing Instead of Price and Territorial Segregation of the Housing Market. (2003) Moscow: IEG [online]. Available from: http://www.urbaneconomics.ru/projects/?mat_id=12&page_id=38 (in Russian)

24. Vetrov, G.Yu. (2001) Russian Urbanisation on the Crossroads: Towards a «Garden City» or Towards a «Vegetable Garden City»? Scenarios of Development for Russian Cities. Moscow: IEG. Available from: http://sbiblio.com/biblio/archive/vetrov_rossurbannaper/ (in Russian)

25. Vendina, О. (2008) A Requiem to Public Spaces of Moscow. Arkhitekturny Vestnik. No. 2. [online]. Available from: http://archvestnik.ru/ru/magazine/av-2-101-2008/rekviem-po-obshchestvenn... (in Russian)

26. Moscow at a Breakeven Point. «AV» Survey. The editors interview B.V.Levyant, Head, АВД Architects. Arkhitekturny Vestnik. 2010. No. 2 (in Russian)

27. Moscow at a Breakeven Point. «AV» Survey. The editors interview A.A.Vysokovsky, President, «Urban Planning Reforms» Foundation. Arkhitekturny Vestnik. 2010. No. 5 (in Russian)

28. Moscow at a Breakeven Point. «AV» Survey. The editors interview Vladimir Yudintsev, Head, ARTE+ architecture consultancy. Arkhitekturny Vestnik. 2010. No. 6 (in Russian)

29. Ovsyannikov, V. Conceptual project «Living Earth» (social background and organization principles). Section 2. Basic socio-functional models and requirements concerning spatial organization of new residential estates. Web-site of the Panel of Experts of the President of the Russian Federation for Realisation of Priority National Projects and Demographic Policy [online]. Available from: http://www.rusdb.ru/project/library/jivaya_zemlya/2/ (in Russian)

30. Possibilities and variants of overcoming social segregation of «new citizens». Web-site of the Panel of Experts of the President of the Russian Federation for Realisation of Priority National Projects and Demographic Policy [online]. Available from: http://www.rusdb.ru/gorod/report/4-5-3/ (in Russian)

31. Glazychev, V.L. (2009) Political Economy of the City. Moscow: Delo, ANH (in Russian)

32. August, M. (2008) Social Mix and Canadian Public Housing Redevelopment: Experiences in Toronto. Canadian Journal of Urban Research. June 22. [online]. Available from: http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Social+mix+and+Canadian+public+housing+red...

33. Kramkova, Т.V. (2009) Construction of Housing and Housing Policy in Switzerland. Property and Investments. Legal Regulation. No. 4 (in Russian)

34. Bauman, Z. (2008) City of Fears, City of Hopes. Logos. No. 3. [online]. Available from: http://www.intelros.ru/pdf/logos_03_2008/02.pdf (in Russian)

Russian text of this article

ISSN 1990-4126  Registration MCM el. № ФС 77-70832 of 30.08.2017 © USUAA, 2004-2017  © Architecton, 2004-2017