№58
June 2017
ISSN
1990-4126

Russian

«Architecton: proceedings of higher education» № 48 December 2014

Architectural critique


Shvets Anna V.

PhD student,
Department of Theory of Architecture and Professional Communications.
Research supervisor: Associate Professor I.V. Tarasova, PhD. (Architecture).
Ural State Academy of Architecture and Arts,
Ekaterinburg, Russia, e-mail: eremina_shvec@inbox.ru  

Tarasova Irina V.

PhD. (Architecture), Associate Professor, Dean of Architecture.
Ural State Academy of Architecture and Arts,
Ekaterinburg, Russia, e-mail: LITICIAS@yandex.ru  

ASPECTS OF THE SYSTEMS APPROACH TO ARCHITECTURAL CRITICISM


Based on the reading of the book «Architecture and Critical Imagination» by Wayne Attoe, American professor and critic of architecture, the author suggests a method of systemic criticism and proposes tools for evaluating contemporary architectural projects.

Key words: architectural criticism, critical evaluation, interpretation in architecture, the system "Architecture", the system «Author's assessment», critical identification



References

  1. Attoe, W. (1978) Architecture and Critical Imagination. London: John Wiley.
  2. Tilghman, B. R. (1979) Architecture and Critical Imagination by Wayne Attoe. In: The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism. No.3. [Online] Available from: http://www.jstor.org/stable/430808
  3. Pattabi, G. (2000) The Production of Architectural Criticism. In: Architectural Theory Review. No. 1. Edinburgh.
  4. Agoshkova, E.B. (1998) The Evolution of the Concept of System. Voprosy Filosofii. No. 7 (in Russian).
  5. Babich, V.N., Kholodova, L.P. (2011) The Methodology of Systems Analysis in Architecture [Online] Architecton: Proceedings of Higher Education. No. 34. Available from: http://archvuz.ru/2011_2/3 (in Russian)
  6. Zavarikhin, S.P. (1989) Russian Architectural Criticism: Mid 18th – Early 20th Century. Leningrad: Leningrad University (in Russian).
  7. Ilyichev, L.F. (1983) Philosophical Encyclopaedic Dictionary. Moscow: Sovetskaya Encyclopedia (in Russian).
  8. Korotkovsky, A.E. (1975) Introduction to Architectural Composition Modelling. Moscow: MArhI (in Russian).
  9. Korikov, A.M. (1989) Foundations of Systems Analysis and Theory of Systems. Tomsk: TGU (in Russian)
  10. Kislykh, T.A. (2008) A Model for Systematising the Methods of Critical Analysis of an Architectural Object [Online] Architecton: Proceedings of Higher Education. No. 22 (Supplement). Available from: http://archvuz.ru/2008_22/38 (in Russian)
  11. Fesenko, D. (2010) Theory of the Architectural Process: the Contours of a New Paradigm. Moscow: Architectural Bulletin (in Russian).
  12. Shvets, A.V. Tarasova, I.V. (2014) Doctrinal criticism as One of the Methods of Architectural Criticism [Online] Architecton: Proceedings of Higher Education. No. 46. Available from: http://archvuz.ru/2014_2/22 (in Russian)


Russian text of this article

ISSN 1990-4126  Registration MCM el. № ФС 77-50147 of 06.06.2012 © USUAA, 2004-2017  © Architecton, 2004-2017